Re: First Timer
Fisherman's World: (845-297-9664) Bloods at $9 a dozen. I tried to get herring from him a few days ago for a short evening of fishing and he told me he could only sell me a 10 pack (WTF??) so I just got bloods from him. Last year I was getting a 2 pack of herring from him, and for the record, it was def was mushy garbage most of the time.
**The Lake House: (845-297-3184) Bloods at $7.50 a dozen. Herring has been fresh all this year, and will sell in packs of 2.
Do yourself a favor and buy your tackle before you head out here, there is a good chance neither shop will have everything you're looking for. But Dick's in the Poughkeepsie Galleria prob will. Make sure you call the shops before you go because they both run out of bait pretty often.