Originally Posted by AllNightJay
If your fishing a rocky area and there is no visible signs of fish feeding. How do you pick your plug. How can you find out what bait fish are in the area. I know in Maine Mackerel, shad and herring are local bait fish but not sure if they are around all season. Should I just try all three patterns and maybe a Slug-go or stick to one single plug.
Whats the deal Jay my man, when we going fishing again?? My daughter is going on vacation in Mass for 3 1/2 weeks starting Saturday so I'm gonna have oodles of time on my hands, weeknights, weekends and the like. I got ur #, I'll give ya a jingle sometime soon.
As far as answering ur question, YES would be the simple answer to all. It's never a bad idea to have a variety of plugs available no matter where ur fishing as stripers can be fickle as hell sometimes. Stick to the basic principles of plugging using lighter colored/brighter lures (white/silver/spinnerbaits) with a faster retrieve during the day. Blue/green/olive/bubblegum over white all can be very effective, pencil poppers and needlefish are two of my favorites followed by a shiny silver like a Deadly Dick or Kastmaster. If ur fishing rocks at night (I'm assuming you're talking Hills Beach/Biddeford Pool) try darker patterns, (black on grey seems to be popular) be they shad, mackerel/herring pattern or more along the lines of a sluggo or Fin S. At dusk as the sun is setting, blurple (blue/purple) seems to be the color of choice, not so much from personal experience, but on the recommendation of many others on this site. Good luck out there man, let me know when ur ur heading out this weekend, maybe we can meet up.
StriperHyper ~ Will